Search Icon
MLB - The guaranteed-money scandal

MLB – The guaranteed-money scandal

Why MLB makes NBA and NFL stars look small MLB Logo

Talk money with a US sports fan and theyll rattle off LeBron James salary or Patrick Mahomes latest check. Wrong angle. If you want the real dizzying numbers, you have to dig into the dirt on the diamond.

MLB sits on the most outrageous financial secret in sport, and it is kept under lock and key. This is the jackpot. We are not just talking about a few tens of millions thrown around. We are talking about ironclad deals, sealed tight and carved in stone. A perfectly legal heist that leaves huge NFL stars looking broke by comparison. Lets unpack the accounting oddity that drives franchise owners up the wall.

The NFL mirage versus baseballs locked vault MLB Logo

In the NFL, agents love blasting out glossy headlines on social media. A quarterback signs for 250 million? Half the time its just smoke and mirrors, marketing fluff designed to get the clicks rolling. One sore knee, one drop in form, and the franchise can rip up the script and send the player packing with scraps as consolation. The league can be brutal.

MLB works more like a tax haven for pro athletes. When a slugger inks a 300 million deal over ten years, every last cent is guaranteed. Break a clavicle the next day, forget how to hit a ball, or rock up in spring camp 20 pounds heavier, and the bank still has to send the full amount. Right through to the final day.

The MLB players union: a legal machine nobody can touch MLB Logo

How did this kind of madness ever take root in the home of ultra-capitalism? The answer fits in five letters: MLBPA. The baseball players union is, without question, the fiercest, most powerful and most ruthless organisation in sport.

Since the huge strikes of the 90s, they have methodically bent the owners to their will. No concessions. None. They have protected the 100 percent guaranteed-money rule by force. The owners can moan at every collective bargaining round, but the players do not give an inch. Its untouchable war chest.

$0.99
7-day trial
Full Pro access.
Try it for $0.99.
Picks · Injury reports · Trends · Tools · No ads — no commitment

The Bobby Bonilla effect: paid to do nothing until retirement MLB Logo

The other insane part of this system is the art of deferred money. The Bobby Bonilla case is so absurd it gets taught in American business schools. The man has not played a MLB game since 2001. Yet every 1 July, the New York Mets dutifully cut him a cheque for 1.19 million dollars, and that circus runs until 2035.

To spread out colossal payrolls, executives often agree to push payments decades down the line. The result? Overweight retirees earning more while sipping cocktails on the sofa than current NBA suits are grinding out on the hardwood.

The dead weight: when one contract wrecks a team for a decade MLB Logo

For regular fans and bettors, that contract setup changes the whole read. A bad signing hurts in Europe; in MLB, it can kill a franchise stone dead for a good decade. A guy signed for eight years who suddenly loses his edge becomes radioactive dead weight, impossible to move. Nobody wants him.

The team is left handcuffed financially, the payroll blown up, unable to bring in free agents to offset the liability. That is vital when you are sizing up future odds: a club weighed down by two or three toxic guaranteed contracts will never have the flexibility needed to chase a title in October. Avoid those teams like the plague.

Credit: Christian Petersen / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP

Discover the rest of the sports news on our site!

Author


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *