Trey Yesavage shuts down the Yankees: the Blue Jays phenom shrugs off the sophomore slump
What if Toronto’s stunning 2025 surge is no fluke? All offseason, Blue Jays fans worried their young star pitcher Trey Yesavage might take a step back. On Wednesday night at Yankee Stadium, the right-hander brushed aside every doubt, turning in his best outing of the year in a tight 2-1 win over New York. Yesavage blanked the Bronx Bombers for six innings, allowing just two hits and striking out eight to drop his ERA to a tiny 1.07 after five starts.
An unusual build-up to face the best arm in the American League
Even a two-hour rain delay couldn’t knock the rookie off his stride. While he waited, Yesavage sat back, watched his teammates play cards and drank three cans of Red Bull. That cool head helped him win his showdown with Cam Schlittler, the Yankees’ flamethrower who is widely seen as the most fearsome pitcher in the American League right now. “They’re going to be in this league for a long time, and they’re going to dominate,” said Andrés Giménez, clearly enjoying the show put on by the two young aces.
Try it for $0.99.
Aaron Judge put through the grinder
If Yesavage’s breaking ball does serious damage, it was his fastball at the top of the zone that set the tone on Wednesday. Yankees captain Aaron Judge found that out the hard way, striking out in all three plate appearances against the Jays right-hander. True to form, the young pitcher barely blinked after the feat: “He’s a great player, but I try to strike everybody out. It’s nice to do it three times against him, but that’s my goal against every hitter.”
No workload limits for the rest of the season
Slowed by a right shoulder impingement in spring training that delayed his debut by a month, Yesavage may have somehow sidestepped the fatigue trap that often follows a heavy World Series workload. Manager John Schneider was delighted to see his man firing on all cylinders, and confirmed there will be no innings cap on him this summer. After being thrown into the white-hot pressure of the postseason last year, Yesavage is now officially settling into his first proper big-league starting routine, and the Yankees won’t forget it in a hurry.


Leave a Reply