New York Islanders vs Tampa Bay Lightning – Free NHL Prediction – 11/10/2026

New York Islanders vs Tampa Bay Lightning: two stingy defences collide at UBS Arena

Two goals against per game for the Islanders. 2.25 for the Lightning. Saturday night in Elmont brings together two teams that have made life miserable for opposing forwards through the opening fortnight, and that’s the lens for everything that follows.

Puck drop is 7:30 PM ET, so 01:30 Paris time on Sunday. Tampa Bay arrive on a three-game winning streak after sweeping a homestand. New York come in at 2-2, fresh off a convincing 4-1 win over Chicago on Thursday.

The records don’t separate them by much. The underlying numbers don’t either. The Lightning generate more, with 31.3 shots per game against the Islanders’ 24.3, but New York have been more clinical, scoring 3.25 per game against Tampa’s 2.75.

Special teams tilt the other way. The Islanders’ power play runs at 20% and their penalty kill at 86.7%. Tampa’s power play has converted just 6.3% of its chances. That’s a glaring hole for a team with Nikita Kucherov on the first unit.

So which edge matters more: Tampa’s volume or New York’s efficiency? We’ll make the argument below, but the short answer is that the Lightning’s recent run has come with goaltending and defensive detail that travels well.

One thing looks almost certain. Goals won’t come cheap. Both goaltenders have been in form, and neither coach will want this one to turn into a track meet.

New York Islanders: Sorokin’s form and an 86.7% penalty kill, but Barzal still missing

Ilya Sorokin stopped 22 of 23 shots against Chicago on Thursday. The only goal came late in the third period from Frank Nazar, and it ended a lengthy shutout streak for the Islanders’ goaltender. That tells you how well he’s been playing.

Bo Horvat led the way in that 4-1 win with two goals, one on the power play in the first period and one into the empty net. Emil Heineman and Anthony Duclair added the others, and Logan Stanley picked up two assists. Before that, the Islanders had hammered New Jersey 6-0.

There’s a less flattering result in between, a 5-2 loss to the Rangers. That game showed what happens when New York lose control of the middle of the ice. The structure is good. It isn’t bulletproof.

The bigger concern is personnel. Mathew Barzal hadn’t played a game this season heading into Thursday, and his absence takes a lot of creativity out of the lineup. Without him, the Islanders rely more heavily on Horvat and on converting a modest shot volume, averaging just 24.3 per game.

That’s a thin margin to work with against a team that’s out-shooting opponents. A side this efficient can survive it for a while. Over a full season, it doesn’t bear close inspection.

Home ice does give the Islanders the last change. Expect New York to steer their best defensive pair toward Kucherov’s line and try to keep the game in front of Sorokin, where they’ve been at their best.

FREE

2-week trial
no renewal

Full GOAT access.
Free for 2 weeks.

Picks · Injury reports · Trends · AI Chatbot · Cappers’ Corner — no commitment

Let’s do it

Tampa Bay Lightning: three straight wins and a goaltender who stopped 34 on debut

Dennis Hildeby made 34 saves in his first game for Tampa Bay on Thursday. The Lightning beat Minnesota 3-2, completing a perfect three-game homestand, and the new goaltender was the reason they held off a late push.

John Carlson was the other story. Two goals, his first two since arriving in Tampa, and nine shots on goal, more than anyone else in the game. Anthony Cirelli added the third, and Kucherov set up two. With Carlson driving play from the blue line, the Lightning have a second source of offence beyond their forwards.

The run before that was built on defence. Wins over Washington 3-1 and Philadelphia 4-1 meant Tampa conceded four goals across their three-game streak. They allow 2.25 per game overall on 24.3 shots, which means opponents are getting very little.

The weak spot is the power play. 6.3% is poor by any standard, and it’s up against an Islanders penalty kill above 86%. Tampa won’t win this on special teams. They’ll need to do it at even strength, where their shot volume of 31.3 per game gives them the clear advantage.

Three wins on the bounce. The confidence is there.

The trip north is the only question mark. After three straight games at home, Saturday is their first outing away from Tampa since that run began. Against a team that kills 86.7% of penalties and has a goaltender in Sorokin’s form, the Lightning can ill afford a slow first period.

Probable lineup New York Islanders: Not announced at time of publication
Probable lineup Tampa Bay Lightning: Not announced at time of publication

Free NHL Prediction: New York Islanders vs Tampa Bay Lightning

Our prediction: Tampa Bay Lightning to win

The even-strength gap is the core of the case. Tampa Bay out-shoot opponents heavily, 31.3 per game against 24.3 allowed, while the Islanders are averaging the same 24.3 shots going the other way. Over sixty minutes, that volume edge should tell, especially against a New York lineup still missing Barzal’s creativity.

Form backs it up. The Lightning have won three straight, conceded four goals in that run, and found a new attacking threat in Carlson. Hildeby’s 34-save debut also means Tampa have a goaltending option in form, whichever way the rotation falls.

The risk is Sorokin, and the Islanders’ special teams, which are clearly better. That’s why we expect a low-scoring, one-goal game rather than a comfortable road win. Final odds hadn’t settled at the time of writing, so check the price before puck drop, but our pick is Tampa Bay to take it.

MathODDS App

Your picks,
in your pocket.

Predictions · Trends · Tools · Injury reports
Real-time notifications & alerts

Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play

MathODDS

→

★★★★★