MLB : the Yankees hold their breath over Aaron Judge, the injury worrying all of New York

The captain is on the bench, and the whole Bronx is watching the medical room

Aaron Judge on the bench two nights in a row at Yankee Stadium is never just another scene. In the Yankees’ world, some silences are louder than a home run into the right-field seats. And since Wednesday, New York has had that uneasy feeling: their captain isn’t just being rested, he might be more hurt than first thought.

The initial diagnosis pointed to a bone bruise near the right rib cage. A New York-based specialist backed up that first read, but also called for more tests. Not exactly the sort of update that calms a club already missing its best player for two games.

Aaron Boone summed it up after the 5-4 loss to the Guardians: the Yankees want clearer images. In plain English, they’re trying to work out exactly what’s going on before they set a timetable, a plan, or a possible trip to the injured list.

A pain that’s been hanging around for two weeks

What worries them most isn’t just Judge’s absence. It’s how long this has been going on. According to Aaron Boone, the slugger has felt discomfort in his right shoulder for around two weeks, mainly when he swings the bat.

Judge hasn’t been able to point to one specific play that caused it. No obvious dive, no collision, no dramatic moment to blame. Just a nagging issue that creeps in, messes with the swing, and eventually forces the staff to shut things down.

And when the machine in question is Aaron Judge, the Yankees really can’t afford to shrug it off.

$0.99

7-day trial

Full Pro access.
Try it for $0.99.

Picks · Injury reports · Trends · Tools · No ads — no commitment

Let’s do it

The numbers were already telling a story

Even before the injury became public, Judge’s offensive output had started to dip. Since 11 May, he’s managed just 14 hits in 68 plate appearances, a .206 average, with one home run, eight RBI and 19 strikeouts.

For most players, that’s a bad run. For Judge, it’s a warning sign.

For the season overall, his numbers still look strong: .248/.375/.533, 17 homers and 38 RBI in 59 games. But the gap to his usual standard is obvious. The swing looks less free, the threat less constant, the damage less severe.

In a MLB season, slumps happen. But when they line up with pain in the ribs or shoulder, the concern gets a whole lot heavier.

The 2019 memory is impossible to ignore

Around the Yankees, this part of the body brings back a nasty memory. In 2019, Judge had already dealt with a significant issue on the right side of his ribs after a diving catch. The damage was serious: a stress fracture in the first right rib and a partially collapsed lung.

The wild part is that he kept playing through it right into the playoffs. If the 2020 season hadn’t been pushed back by the pandemic, Judge probably would have opened the year on the injured list and stayed there until June.

That’s why New York is moving carefully. The Yankees know pain in this area can mean more than simple discomfort. And they know Judge is the kind of player who’ll play through anything, sometimes for too long.

Boone is not ruling out the injured list

For now, nothing has been decided. The Yankees still don’t know whether Judge will need a stint on the injured list. But Wednesday night, they weren’t ruling it out either.

That’s usually where the tension starts to build. A club wants its biggest player available, especially in the middle of the season. But it also has to avoid turning a manageable issue into a long-term injury. In Judge’s case, the temptation to wait it out is obvious. So is the danger.

Boone wants the exact nature of the problem nailed down first. Once the tests are done, the Yankees can finally choose a path: a short rest, a longer absence, specific treatment, or an unavoidable move to the medical list.

Without Judge, the Yankees have to prove they’re more than one man

Gerrit Cole said it plainly: Aaron Judge matters a lot to this team. Not just because he hits hard and can flip an inning with one swing. But because he brings a presence. Energy. A kind of gravity to the lineup.

When Judge is in there, everybody breathes a little easier. So do the opposing pitchers.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. still made an important point: the Yankees are a team. Judge is huge, but he can’t do it all on his own. And if this absence lasts, New York will have to find answers elsewhere. In the bats of its other leaders, in the depth, in the discipline at the plate, in the ability not to turn every game without Judge into a mental test.

José Caballero started in right field on Tuesday and Wednesday in his place. It’s not the same presence. Not the same weight in the batter’s box. But that’s a long season for you: surviving when the original plan starts to crack.

An injury landing at the worst possible time

The Yankees didn’t need this uncertainty. A tight loss to Cleveland, a captain waiting on tests, a staff refusing to give a timetable, and an offense that already has to adjust: it’s a messy mix.

Judge has won three of the last four American League MVP awards. At 34, he’s still the face of the franchise, the player opponents build their plan around, the one fans pay to see and teammates follow.

Lose him for a few days and it’s a problem. Lose him for several weeks and the whole feel of the New York season changes.

New York waits for the scans, and holds its breath

For now, the Yankees still don’t have a final answer. They know there’s discomfort. They know a specialist confirmed the initial diagnosis. They also know more detailed tests are needed. And in elite sport, that kind of update is usually enough to set the alarm bells ringing.

Aaron Judge hasn’t spoken publicly since the series against the Athletics. The club, meanwhile, is treading carefully.

In New York, everyone knows what a Judge home run feels like. They also know the hole he leaves when his name is missing from the lineup.

The Yankees just want to know what they’re dealing with.

So does the whole Bronx.

Discover the rest of the sports news on mathodds!